A short story by Martin Christen
I sat in front of the telephone, completely numb. I couldn’t comprehend what had just happened. My brother Klaus had just called to inform me that he would not be attending this year’s family Christmas celebration. Furthermore, his family wouldn’t be attending either. In particular, he forbade me from having any contact with his daughter, Laura. He claimed that I had abused her and that he was going to put a stop to it. On top of that, he stated that he did not agree with the way my wife, Eva, and I practiced an open marriage. But I had to snap out of my paralysis, stand up, go to Eva, and tell her.
A few years prior, in 1993, my mother had passed away. She had always been the one holding the family together by inviting all four of her children, along with their spouses and grandchildren, to the Christmas celebration every year. Since her death, we siblings took turns hosting the Christmas party, and this year it was my turn (presumably 1995). Just last week, I had sent out the invitations to my siblings and our father, letting them know exactly when Eva and I would be expecting the rest of the family. And now this. What was going on here? What exactly was I being accused of? I had to find out.
First, I recalled a telephone conversation with Laura that had taken place that summer, which had left me quite shaken. She had called me, and the conversation went something like this:
“Do you actually know, dear Uncle Martin, what my father is telling the other relatives about you?”
“No, I don’t. What is it?”
“Well, my daddy is telling very terrible things about you and speaks very badly of you.”
“Well, I am aware that my brother and I don’t always see eye to eye, and disagreements among brothers are a part of life. Surely it won’t be quite as bad as you fear.”
She explained to me that I should watch out for my older brother, but I brushed it off and didn’t take the warning seriously.
One thing was clear for now: this year’s Christmas celebration was canceled. Under these circumstances, I had no desire to continue making preparations, let alone justify myself to any of my relatives. So, I made a round of phone calls to cancel the event.
Reactions of the Siblings
I called my other brother, Beat, and explained right away why there would be no family Christmas this year. Beat said that his wife, Vreni, and he had already heard these accusations from Klaus. Vreni had commented: “Well, if all of that is true, then of course you have to involve the police.” My father said he was deeply disappointed and had not expected something like this from me. My sister said, “That is humbug. I know my little brother. Of course, that never happened.”
Oof! At least my sister was standing by me, not to mention my wife, who never for a single second doubted my integrity. But what I heard from the rest of the family shook me deeply. I would have expected my father, in particular, to at least ask for my side of the story first. He was the one who always preached how important justice was and that one must hear all sides before passing judgment.
But now, of course, I wondered where these accusations even came from. On what basis does something like this arise? And how could I clear up this situation and rid the world of these allegations? There was only one way: I had to talk to my brother. But I didn’t want to face him completely alone. On the one hand, I wanted my wife by my side, and on the other, I granted my brother the same right. Furthermore, I had a hunch that the accusation might have originated from her. Two couples sitting across from each other, hurling accusations? That didn’t sound like a pleasant evening. Then it occurred to me that we could involve a neutral observer and mediator.
So, I called my brother again and suggested meeting with him and his wife, along with my own wife and a neutral mediator. I offered the services of my own psychologist, whom I had been seeing regularly for a while, but of course, he was free to make other suggestions. He thought it was a good idea, but requested that the four of us meet with his family therapists. It was a therapist couple, which he felt was a good constellation and had been helpful to him and his wife so far. I agreed, and a date was soon found. I also pointed out that, in my opinion, Laura should be present at this meeting. She was old enough by then (about 15 at the time) and could certainly best explain for herself whether and what kind of abuse had occurred by my hands and what she was accusing me of. Klaus, however, categorically refused. The poor girl had already been through enough, he said; we had to settle this among ourselves. As it turned out later, my assumption that the therapists would approach the situation neutrally and act as a calming influence on all sides was completely off the mark.
A Memorable Session with Family Therapists
We met at the practice of these family therapists. The first thing I did was ask what exactly I was being accused of and on what evidence. The following episodes were presented to me as proof:
First, it had happened that on a Sunday morning, Laura had come into the parents’ bedroom, climbed into the marital bed with them, crawled onto her father’s stomach, and performed “unmistakable” movements there. They reasoned that Laura must have learned this behavior somewhere, and she could only have learned it from me. As a result, they had to ban Laura from the parental bedroom as an educational measure.
Second, they claimed Laura’s dependency on me was clearly visible during a visit to Lenk, where Laura had climbed up me to greet me and rubbed herself against my trousers in a shocking manner. And I, apparently, had clearly enjoyed it.
Third, I was accused of having harassed Rita’s sister at Klaus and Rita’s wedding.
Fourth, Laura had allegedly said that she regularly slept in my bed.
Now I tried to make sense of these accusations. First, you have to know that Rita is Klaus’s second wife and Laura’s stepmother. Laura comes from Klaus’s first marriage. This first marriage of Klaus was doomed from the start; they separated after just one year, shortly after their daughter Laura was born. Since Sandra led rather an unstable life and was frequently on the move, she placed her daughter with a foster mother. One fine day, this foster mother contacted Klaus with a request to reimburse her costs, stating she hadn’t received any money from the child’s mother for several months. Klaus began investigating and discovered that Sandra had moved away to an unknown destination and was essentially missing. No official agency knew where to find her. Klaus therefore paid the foster mother’s bills directly, stopped alimony payments to the mother, and filed an official petition to take over custody of his daughter. This was not a problem at all, since the mother was missing. Klaus also noticed that the foster family did not care for Laura as lovingly as one would hope. Based on welts and bruises, it was determined that Laura had even been beaten there. So, Klaus removed his daughter from the foster parents. He was alone and had to work. Therefore, he handed Laura over to the care of his mother, her grandmother. The girl was about five years old—and I myself was twenty, in the middle of my engineering studies, still living with my parents. The little girl brought a lot of joy and life into the house for my mother, father, and me. I spent a lot of time with her, told her stories, sang songs with her, put her to bed, played games with her, brushed her teeth with her, and kissed her goodnight. Once, she couldn’t fall asleep, and I even lay down next to her in her bed until she slept (so much for the fourth accusation). We played with the cat together, and I explained the world to her as best as I could to a six-year-old. In the meantime, Klaus met and fell in love with a new girlfriend, and soon there was talk of marriage. Everyone was happy that he had found such a great woman; Rita was a teacher, and soon there was a big wedding celebration (that was on May 20, 1983). Naturally, as a young man in his prime, I also flirted with the women present who were around my age, including Rita’s pretty sister. What exactly I was supposed to have done to her was a mystery to me; I had only talked to her and perhaps touched her arms. Nothing more, and certainly no sex had taken place, either consensual or non-consensual. I said as much at the therapist session, and for me, the matter was settled. Rita, however, argued that I had gone too far with my touching and that her sister had felt extremely uncomfortable in my presence. I said that whatever wrong I might have done or said in my hormonal exuberance, I was sorry, but there had definitely been no sex. Well, so much for the third accusation.
Furthermore: I remember well the scene when the bridal couple said goodbye at that wedding celebration. The little girl, Laura, the groom’s daughter, ran after them cheering, shouting how happy she was to finally be able to live with her daddy and her new mommy again. The two looked at each other and told Laura that she couldn’t come with them right now. She would stay with her grandmother for a while longer. That was the agreement, so that the newlywed couple could first get used to their life together and prepare a home for Laura. Laura could perhaps join them in a year or so, but not before. Oh boy, that caused tears. The little girl didn’t understand what she was being told and was inconsolable, even though her grandmother rushed over and pressed her favorite doll into her arms. And so, Laura spent another year and her kindergarten days with her grandma, grandpa, and me, her uncle.
A year later, as promised, word came from Klaus that Laura was now welcome in the marital home (this was around March 1984, after Klaus had taken over a condominium). She was finally allowed to go there and was overjoyed. Life at our home became a bit slower and quieter without the little one, and everyone went back to their usual routines, or in my case, to my engineering studies. A few months later, a call came from Rita. She desperately wanted to talk to me. She asked me if I had ever done anything sexual with Laura. Whether I had ever abused her. I rejected this accusation in horror and asked how she could arrive at such an absurd suspicion. And now, looking back, I remember that this was the first time she brought up accusation number one—the story about Laura’s “unmistakable” movements on her father’s stomach, and that she could only have learned this from me. I was speechless back then, and I still am today. What was I supposed to imagine by these “unmistakable” movements? I had no idea what that meant, nor how it was supposed to connect to me. That was the first accusation.
And now we come to accusation number two: the visit to Lenk. For this story, I have to back up a bit. Lenk in the Simmental was the traditional skiing holiday destination of my parents and thus the whole family. Year after year, as children, we went to Lenk with our parents, always staying in the same chalet, which belonged to a friendly couple from the city of Bern. The chalet had two apartments; we occupied one for two weeks, and the owners were sometimes in the other for their own holidays when their plans allowed. When they were there, there were frequent mutual visits, which usually involved playing a lot of Jass (a Swiss card game). After we children grew up and started our own families—I had recently met Eva and her children—we still occasionally went to Lenk when it could be arranged. On one occasion, we were able to use the said chalet (it must have been around 1989), while Klaus independently booked a cheap hotel in the village for his family. Since we heard about each other’s holiday plans, we reserved an evening for his family to visit us and spend the evening together. No sooner said than done; our apartment was polished to a shine, the food cooked, and the final preparations underway when I heard Klaus’s car pull into the driveway. The car door flew open, and I heard Laura jump out of the car, cheering: “Yay! I finally get to see my favorite Uncle Martin again!” She ran around the house, through the front door, and jumped right into my outstretched arms, which I opened to receive her with a smile. We embraced for a while, and then she climbed down. Behind her, Klaus and Rita stood in the doorway, looking completely horrified at the greeting scene that had just unfolded before them. Rita shook my hand frostily, and the rest of the evening proceeded just as frostily. However, Eva and I didn’t even notice it at the time; we simply remained friendly and blamed the poor atmosphere on the dismal weather that had prevailed all day, which can easily ruin a holiday mood.
But in any case, I asked at the therapist session:
“What did I do wrong there? I am not aware of any fault. After all, it was Laura who threw her arms around my neck, not me pulling her toward me. And besides: if I had raped or abused her, it would be completely unthinkable for her to approach me with such joy. It would have to be quite the opposite—she would be afraid of me and try to hide from me!”
“In any case, it is not normal behavior between an uncle and a niece,” the therapist said.
“What do you mean?”
“Well, it’s not normal for an uncle and a niece to greet each other in this manner.”
“But how could I have prevented that? As I said, it was Laura who jumped up at me, not me at her. I simply accepted the greeting. How else should I have reacted?”
“Well, you should have put Laura in her place.”
“Excuse me?”
“Yes, you should have pushed her away, kept her at a proper distance, shaken her hand, and said: ‘Hello Laura, I’m glad to see you too, but we are uncle and niece, and an uncle and a niece only greet each other with a handshake.'”
I was speechless at that. My wife also looked on with utter incomprehension. What kind of a loveless society was this? It had simply been an emotional outburst. Of course, Laura had a particularly close relationship with me; after all, we had spent about two years of her young life together. And that is supposed to be suppressed? I had a strong feeling that my brother had realized he didn’t share such an affectionate bond with his daughter as he would wish. And then he had to witness her loving his brother and her uncle more than him. It could only be jealousy. And these therapists were actually reinforcing him in this? I couldn’t believe my ears.
Gender-Segregated Session
The therapists then suggested that we separate by gender and talk man-to-man and woman-to-woman. The female therapist, Rita, and Eva went into the next room, while the male therapist, Klaus, and I remained behind. And now, both of them tag-teamed me about how out of line I was, how much I had pressured Laura (at least by now they accepted that it wasn’t a case of sexual abuse, reducing it to “emotional abuse”). They insisted I had to recognize my wrongdoings and preferably seek therapy because of it. Under no circumstances was I allowed to encounter Laura in that manner again, like back in Lenk, for instance. I was completely intimidated and was merely trying to defend myself. Time and again, I argued that Laura had a right to her emotions and to express them, and that we shouldn’t strip her of that right. But neither of them wanted to hear it. After about half an hour, the women rejoined us.
The Unfortunate Visit to Rita
Now that everyone was back together, I suddenly remembered the sentence about the disapproval of our open marriage. But I didn’t lead an open marriage with Eva at all! A vague suspicion began to dawn on me. A few years earlier, it must have been around 1988, I had attended a seminar in the Grisons. If I remember correctly, the seminar was called “Leadership,” and it was about personal development, about bringing out the best in oneself. Gender issues and the interactions between men and women, both in relationships and in the workplace, had been important topics. The seminar ended on Monday at noon, and I drove back home to Hunzenschwil. It’s quite a long distance, taking several hours, and about halfway through, I remembered that I was driving close to my brother’s home in Bülach. I decided to pay them a brief, spontaneous visit. My brother himself wouldn’t be home, of course, but at work, but his wife and perhaps his children would surely be there, and I would enjoy chatting with them for a bit. No sooner said than done; I soon rang the doorbell, and Rita opened the door, surprised.
“Hi Rita, I’m on my way home from a seminar and decided to drop by spontaneously, provided I’m not interrupting. I don’t want to cause any trouble, but perhaps I could have a coffee and chat a bit? I’m still buzzing and on a high from the seminar.”
“Yes, of course, come in. Tell me, what kind of seminar was it?”
And so, we sat down at the dining table in front of the kitchen-living area; Laura also came rushing in happily and joined us. I talked enthusiastically about the seminar. The details are unimportant, and I barely remember them anyway, but what stood out was this: when I eventually touched upon the topic of sexuality and used the German words for cock and pussy, I had Laura’s undivided attention (she was about 10 years old at the time), but Rita turned pale and said Laura had to go to her room immediately. When I asked in confusion what had happened, she said that at their table and in front of children, one does not speak of such things, nor use such words. I was not accustomed to such prudishness and tried to defend myself. But it was of little use. After a few sentences, Rita stood up and went behind the kitchen counter to wash the cups. I followed her and tried to placate her. I hugged her from behind and said it wasn’t that bad, as a gesture of reconciliation. This, however, went completely down the wrong pipe; she spun around, slapped me across the face, and said: “Leave my house immediately! You have no business here anymore!” Completely bewildered, I grabbed my jacket, left the apartment, got into my car, and drove off. I didn’t understand at all what had just happened to me.
At the therapist session, I said something to Rita along the lines of:
“I just remembered that I visited you once in Bülach. Perhaps I misbehaved there.”
“Yes, indeed, you said ugly things in front of Laura, and you grabbed my breasts, so I had to throw you out of the house to defend myself.”
“I don’t recall grabbing your breasts, but whatever exactly happened: I accept that it was totally out of line, that I crossed a boundary, and I would like to apologize to you in all due form.”
A palpable sigh of relief went through the room. You could almost feel the tension evaporate. Finally, he sees his faults! So that was the accusation pointing toward the “open marriage.”
On this positive note, we were able to wrap things up, and the session ended with a sense of understanding and forgiveness.
On the way home, Eva told me that the exact same thing had happened to her with the women as it had to me with the men. The two women had lectured her continuously about what a bad guy I was, what wrongs I had committed, and that she had to accept that I was a perpetrator who needed to be institutionalized or locked away. Over time, she hadn’t known which way was up, her head was spinning, but she just kept repeating that they were wrong, that I hadn’t done it, and that she would continue to stand by me. I was endlessly grateful to her for that. If she had doubted me for even a single moment, I would have lost the ground beneath my feet.
Laura’s Holiday Overnight Stay with Lea
As a small insert, here is another story. While it didn’t feature directly in the abuse accusation negotiations, it sheds further light on the family events surrounding Laura:
Around 1989—I was living in Hunzenschwil with Eva and the children, Lea and Marc, at the time—my mother came to visit one beautiful summer day, bringing Laura along. Laura was currently spending a week or two on holiday with her grandma because her parents were occupied elsewhere. Laura and Lea soon went up to Lea’s room and played harmoniously together. Lea’s things were highly interesting to Laura, like her wardrobe or her makeup. Meanwhile, the three of us adults chatted on the terrace. At the end of the afternoon, when it was time to say goodbye, Laura didn’t want to leave and said she wanted to spend the night with Lea and us. Whether that might be possible. Mother thought it over for a moment, then agreed. No sooner said than done; we set up a sleeping arrangement for Laura in Lea’s room and had a lovely time until the next day at noon, when Grandma picked her up again.
A few weeks later, during another visit from my mother, she showed us a multi-page letter she had received from Rita. In this letter, Rita ranted about how Mother had committed a massive breach of trust by leaving Laura with us for the night. After all, she, Rita, had entrusted Laura to Grandma’s care and assumed that Grandma would exercise that care at all times. If she left Laura overnight with “a stranger,” then she could no longer guarantee anything. She, Rita, would have to reconsider whether Laura would ever be allowed to go on holiday to Grandma’s again if such things were to happen there. She noted, for example, that she had to immediately confiscate the lipstick Laura had received as a gift from Lea, because such things were entirely inappropriate for children and conveyed a false image of femininity.
My mother no longer understood the world and asked Eva and me if we could explain it to her. But unfortunately, we couldn’t either; we too sat before this letter in complete bewilderment. In hindsight, it becomes clear to me that Rita was terrified that I might abuse Laura “again” on such an occasion.
In any case, my relationship with my brothers and my father was shattered. From then on, I no longer felt comfortable “in the bosom of my family.” Instead, I felt like the black sheep that had to carry all the sins. Only my relationship with my sister remained unclouded, thanks to her firm conviction that the accusations were fabricated out of thin air, and her optimism that the family would eventually find its way back together. But it didn’t just dissolve. Rather, after the therapist session, the subject was simply never spoken of again; it was silenced, as if it had been banished from the world.
Laura is Angry
For years afterward, the entire matter kept running through my mind. I racked my brain trying to figure out what I could have possibly done to Laura. Contact with her broke off completely—partly because Klaus had forbidden me from reaching out, and partly because I began to distrust myself, slowly almost believing that I must have done something wicked that deserved punishment. It wasn’t until 2013, nearly 20 years later and shortly before my father’s death, that contact was re-established. We chatted via Facebook, and eventually, I visited her in Flawil, where she lives today—now 35 years old, a mother of two, an independent woman fighting her way through life. I took the opportunity to bring up this old story. She was utterly shocked. She had known almost nothing about it. Her stepmother hadn’t talked to her about it and refused to give any information when asked. However, she told me she remembered the visit to Lenk very well, how happy she had been to see me, and how she had been terribly chewed out by Rita in the car on the way back because she had greeted me so warmly. She was told that it just wouldn’t do, it wasn’t normal, and she wasn’t allowed to see me anymore if she continued doing such things. Laura had been completely dissolved in tears, unable to comprehend what the problem was, understanding only that they were now taking her favorite uncle away from her as well. And now, hearing my account of what I went through, she grew furious at her father and Rita for what they had done to me. Rita has since passed away from cancer, but there was at least one occasion before her death where I was able to tell her that those accusations had hit me terribly and nearly knocked me off course. She admitted at the time that she realized the accusations had been false, and that she was sorry. I had heard no such thing from Klaus, however. So, Laura said she would definitely be having a serious word with her father.
Klaus’s Retraction
Two months later, in January 2013, my father was doing very poorly; he was close to death and required care in a nursing home. My brother Klaus came to visit Eva and me on a Sunday morning to discuss our father’s situation and how we wanted to handle the financial implications. As he sat down at the table, he began with the following words:
“Before we talk about our father, I want to say something else. I heard that Laura and you talked about the old abuse allegations again.”
I had to counter: “Hold on, hold on! I spoke with Laura about these things for the first and only time a few weeks ago. No more, no less!”
“Yes, okay, the only time then. But in any case, I want to tell you that Rita might have been a bit oversensitive in this area. That was because she herself was abused by an uncle as a child. Regarding the main accusation about Sunday mornings in the marital bed, climbing onto my stomach and so on, I can tell you this: I am now married for the third time, and my third wife brought a little boy of about 6 into the marriage. It’s very similar to how it was with Laura back then. Little Tim also sometimes comes crawling into the warm marital bed with his mother and me on Sunday mornings, and climbs onto my stomach. I’ve watched this and had to say to myself: this is almost exactly the same as it was with Laura back then. And now I have to realize that there is nothing sexual or erotic about it. The boy is obviously just seeking body heat and affection. And I have now come to the realization that the accusations made by Rita at the time were wrong. I would therefore like to apologize in hindsight.”
Oof! A massive weight lifted off my chest. I said:
“You cannot imagine how many years I have waited for exactly these words. How much I have yearned to be redeemed from this accusation that I abused Laura. I thank you for that!”
And yet, I am not sure if it might not already be too late. The whole thing has eaten itself deep, deep into my soul and probably won’t let go of me anytime soon. Those roughly 18 years cannot simply be wiped away. Nevertheless, the fact that these words have now been spoken, that Klaus has apologized to me, creates clarity and brings a certain inner peace.
At least there is regular contact with Laura again now. For me, it feels like a homecoming. I can finally see her again without a guilty conscience. I missed her so much. After all, to me, she is more like a little sister than a niece.
Postscript
The above notes were written over a long period and came to a temporary conclusion in 2013. There is an aftermath now, in August 2022, because my siblings noticed that I haven’t attended the summer family gatherings in recent years, and they would like to bring me closer back into the circle of siblings. For my part, I note: while the situation eased in 2013, it was not completely resolved. One could say the wound has stopped bleeding, but the scar has not yet formed.
For around 20 years, the accusations had simmered and sprayed their poison until Klaus realized there was nothing to be accused of. For 20 years, I had felt like a pariah, an outcast, the black sheep. For 20 years, I was intimidated and didn’t know how to defend myself, didn’t know how to disprove the accusation of a crime I had never committed, how to present evidence of its non-existence. I am still horrified and angry today about the charlatanry of those alleged family therapists, who weren’t too proud to impose completely warped moral concepts onto me. Back then, I didn’t dare resist this garbage out of fear that I would then face legal repercussions all the more.
After being exonerated by Klaus in 2013, there was a sigh of relief. But I still didn’t feel truly good. As I wrote ten years ago, the whole thing has eaten itself deep into my soul and doesn’t let go so easily.
Through my siblings’ kind offer of wanting to do something nice for my sixtieth birthday and to foster our sibling community, the matter came up again. I documented my discomfort, and suddenly everything was back. A downright rage surged up in me regarding the past events and the fact that Klaus had actively turned against me, while Beat and my father had not actively stood up for me. No, I don’t want to make it that easy for them. Something still needs to happen. I don’t have a clear idea of what exactly needs to happen, but in any case, a simple apology won’t cut it. One could say: what smolders for a long time turns into rage at last.
If Ruth has to cry a lot because of this, I am sorry, especially since she is the only one who always said that what Martin is accused of did not take place. I credit her highly for that. Ruth, you are not responsible for your brothers’ behavior. But you must understand that I have my difficulties with forgiving.
But since then, there has been radio silence. For myself, I find that I don’t miss them. My family of origin is cut off, and that is okay. At most, I occasionally wish to maintain contact with Laura, but she has her own life and her own difficulties, and she hopefully understands that she could contact me if she wished to.
Coda
And one more thing: after a few years, my current wife also told me that she had observed me very closely for a long time, especially regarding my interactions with children. And she had come to the conclusion that I have absolutely no pedophilic tendencies. This type of accusation is therefore clearly settled for her.